Introduction
Our story begins on May 20, 2014, when we were the high bidder on a parcel at the annual Maui County tax auction. As Kirk puts it, "we purchased two old and severely dilapidated houses on a double lot in Makawao."
The properties sit on a large corner lot in historic Makawao, a well-known tourist destination in upcountry Maui. Both homes have sweeping ocean views. The main house has four bedrooms, two bathrooms, a large kitchen, living and dining rooms, a laundry room, and two additional rooms suitable for offices. It also includes a separate lower-level unit with three bedrooms, a kitchen, and a bathroom.
The second home was built in 1976 on an adjacent lot split from the original parcel. Smaller, two rooms, a kitchen, and combined living-dining area, it shares the same ocean views as the main house.
These two homes were owned by two sisters, Julia and Moana Ramos. Julia passed away in 2004. Moana remarried and moved to California in the late 1990s. For approximately 26 years, neither sister paid property taxes.
The Purchase and the Waiting Period
After winning the auction, we entered the statutory one-year redemption period under Hawaii law. If the previous owner does not reclaim the property by paying back taxes plus penalties within those twelve months, the high bidder receives a tax deed, a form of title recognized as superior to most other claims.
The redemption period expired in June 2015. Moana did not redeem. The County of Maui issued tax deeds to us for the properties.
The Condition of the Properties and Our Renovation
The properties were uninhabitable. They had been vacant for roughly 26 years. Walls were coated in thick layers of rat excrement; ceilings were black with mold. Kirk describes rats so large that neighborhood cats were afraid of them. His wife visited once and did not return: "The filth was overwhelming and unsanitary."
The third home was already on the property. It had no roof and had been used as a garbage dump, with rats living in the debris. We filled five large dumpsters clearing out the trash, then used the space for tool storage and staging during the renovation.

We also discovered that Moana Ramos was still occupying the property. We allowed her to stay rent-free for approximately seven months. When she finally left, she and others vandalized the homes, smashing walls with sledgehammers, tearing out copper pipes and wiring, gutting the interiors. The police sympathized but said they could not intervene without formal eviction proceedings.
We spent the next seven months and approximately $220,000 rehabilitating the homes. As renovations neared completion, we prepared to sell the smaller home. We were receiving 10 to 15 inquiries per week from interested buyers, and strong interest from prospective tenants for the larger home.
During the cleanup, we contracted Leptospirosis, Malaria, and Lyme disease. Two of us now live with chronic Lyme disease requiring twice-daily chemotherapy for life. Malaria attacks recur without warning.
We received two unsolicited, legitimate offers for the smaller home: one for $650,000 and another for $700,000. Before we could accept either, our attorney Paul Sulla called with news: the sitting judge had ruled against the plaintiffs. We had won, or so he told us. He advised us not to make any moves, as one more probate hearing remained. We listened. That was a mistake.




The Fraudulent Claim Against Our Properties
Shortly before Kirk purchased the properties at the 2014 tax auction, a Maui per-diem judge and local attorney named Fredrick Matson Kelley discovered that the older sister, Julia, had passed away in 2013. He also learned that Moana had passed away after moving to California.
Matson Kelley, with the help of another attorney, David Whittenburg, devised a scheme to appropriate Kirk's properties. The homes had sat untended for 26 years with multiple unpaid liens. To Matson Kelley, they were an irresistible target, properties worth millions that could be taken through a fabricated probate claim.
His strategy was simple: he claimed he had been hired "on behalf of the Estate of Moana P.M. Ramos." In two letters to Kirk, he asserted that Moana's daughter, Kimberly, had retained him to represent the estate and reclaim the properties.
Both claims were provably false. Matson Kelley had not been contacted by Kimberly. He had paid a private investigator, Steve Goodenow of The Hawaii Investigative Group, $3,699.67 to locate her. The investigator's invoice is dated February 19, 2015, before Matson Kelley's first letter to Kirk. If Kimberly had truly hired him, why did he pay nearly $4,000 to find her?
Matson Kelley's letters to Kirk were exercises in word trickery. He cited a 2001 Warranty Deed that, in truth, recorded Kimberly quit-claiming away any interest she held in the property, not acquiring it. He twisted the document's language to fabricate the impression she held ownership rights.
Matson Kelley and David Whittenburg had already formed an LLC into which they planned to transfer the properties. The homes were never destined for any legitimate estate. This is the identical method used to steal valuable land from Native Hawaiian families, a pattern we document elsewhere on this site.
Matson Kelley's Private Investigator Bill (Feb 19, 2015) »
Matson Kelley's First Letter (Feb 24, 2015) »
Matson Kelley's Second Letter (March 6, 2015) »
Our First Attorney: Terrance Revere
Alarmed by Matson Kelley's threatening letters, we hired Terrance M. Revere as our first attorney. We paid him a $25,000 retainer, our entire savings at the time.
For five months, Revere took no meaningful action. He failed to object to any of the plaintiffs' ex-parte motions, including an emergency ex-parte probate order filed without notice to us. It later became clear that Revere was collaborating with the plaintiffs, feeding information to Matson Kelley and Judge Joseph E. Cardoza. Kirk confronted Revere and fired him. Revere refused to return the unused portion of the retainer.
Andrew Chianese: The Attorney Who Fought Back
After firing Revere, we found Andrew Chianese, a young attorney two years out of law school. He was brilliant, ambitious, and honest. He immediately recognized the heart of the fraud: the plaintiffs had no legitimate evidence. Their case was semantic manipulation designed to confuse the court.
Andrew created a three-part plan:
- File a motion to place a lien on our own properties, preventing sale during litigation.
- Send demand letters to Matson Kelley requiring evidence to substantiate the claim.
- Build a counterclaim against the plaintiffs for fraud and extortion.
After roughly a month, the plaintiffs' own secretaries inadvertently sent Andrew the evidence he needed, evidence that would prove the fraud incontrovertibly.
The Deposition That Exposed the Fraud
By this point, Paul J. Sulla had replaced Terrance Revere as our attorney of record. Sulla assigned Lockey White, an experienced attorney from his office, to represent us at Kimberly's deposition.
Ms. White asked Kimberly why she was pursuing the claim. After evasive answers, she asked a direct question: was Kimberly aware that her mother had quit-claimed away her rights to the properties in 2001?
Kimberly answered: "No, I don't think so." Shown the recorded legal document, she said she did not know her name was attached to it. She then admitted Matson Kelley had her sign the affidavit without reading it first.
Ms. White then produced the invoice from The Hawaii Investigative Group, proving Matson Kelley had paid $3,699.67 to locate Kimberly. The invoice was addressed to his law office, signed by him. It predated his claim that Kimberly had hired him.
Before Kimberly could respond, one of her attorneys shouted: "I was not aware of this document. In fact, it's privileged information. I wish it back and for it to be stricken from this and all records."
Note: Demanding destruction of evidence during a legal proceeding constitutes evidence tampering, a misdemeanor in Hawaii. This episode alone raises probable cause for conspiracy to defraud under color of law. Mailing fraudulent documents to steal property valued above one million dollars also potentially constitutes mail fraud, punishable by up to twenty years in prison.
Ms. White refused to return the document. Kimberly then stated she had not been aware of the investigator's search. The fraud was exposed. Read pages 72 through 75 of the full deposition for yourself.
The Betrayal by Paul Sulla
The day after Kimberly's deposition, Paul Sulla called me. "The case is over," he said. "The plaintiffs won."
He explained that the plaintiffs had produced Kimberly's birth certificate and that Chief Judge Joseph E. Cardoza had ruled this settled the matter. Sulla said we had no options left.
This was absurd. The birth certificate was never in dispute. We had always acknowledged Kimberly was Moana's daughter. Our argument, the one Ms. White had just proven at deposition, was that Kimberly had quit-claimed away her property rights in 2001. The birth certificate was irrelevant, and Paul Sulla knew it.
When I challenged him, he simply repeated: "I'm sorry. It's not right, but they have won."
It became clear that Paul Sulla had switched sides. He urged us to settle: the plaintiffs would return only what we had paid for the properties, plus $30,000 to remove the lien Andrew Chianese had placed. I refused. I told him I would go public, our YouTube channel had over 175,000 subscribers and 50 million views. I would expose the corruption myself.
Sulla responded with threats: "If you don't sign, I will withdraw within 24 hours. You will never find another lawyer. The court will grant a default judgment against you, you will get nothing and owe the plaintiffs' attorney fees."
Under duress, facing the loss of everything with no representation, I signed. The settlement forced me to state falsely that "Mr. Sulla himself proved Kimberly was Moana's daughter", a lie. No one had contested her identity. The deed proved it.
Sulla then demanded we pay him an additional $35,000 or he would place a lien on our homes. I refused. Our total legal fees had reached approximately $140,000.
I believe Sulla, our second attorney of record, sacrificed our interests to protect himself ahead of a trial in another case. From my perspective, he threw our family under the bus to save himself, and the people involved protected one another.
How the Judges Enabled the Theft
The verdict was read by Judge Rhonda Loo but signed by Chief Judge Joseph E. Cardoza. Both judges ignored a ruling from the Third Circuit Court, a higher court, that had reversed their premature emergency ex-parte probate order. They simply pretended the reversal did not exist.
Both also ignored the title report from Old Republic National Title Insurance Company, a century-old firm with $91.4 billion in title insurance policies in force, which confirmed our ownership. The plaintiffs never produced a competing title report. No legitimate insurer would stake its reputation on Matson Kelley's claim, because it did not meet the legal definition of a claim.
The Larger Pattern
We are not the only victims. The same conspirators used the identical method in Benjamin v. Kalana, stripping a Native Hawaiian family of 277 acres through the same fraudulent probate scheme, controlled and operated by Hawaiian judges, corrupt attorneys, and their accomplices. Centuries of family land were stolen from future generations.
What We Lost
We lost three homes that we estimate are worth approximately $2 million as-is. We lost our savings, roughly $220,000 in renovation costs and $140,000 in legal fees. We lost our children's inheritance. We contracted chronic diseases requiring lifelong treatment. And we lost years of our lives to a legal battle that was, from the start, an orchestrated theft.
The Attorney's Advice: Offer Fair Payment for Counsel
An attorney who read our story called me with blunt advice: stop looking for pro bono representation and offer to pay a law firm fairly for its work. My YouTube following was no reason to expect anyone to work for free. He asked whether I would stucco a mansion for nothing in exchange for publicity. Of course I would not, and his point was clear.
He explained that, with homes worth approximately $2 million as-is, it made sense to pay competent counsel to evaluate whether we could recover the properties and potentially seek punitive damages. There would be costs and no guarantee of success. I was angry at first, but I thanked him for the advice. I am willing to pay a competent, honest attorney to pursue recovery of our properties.
Seeking Legal Representation
We are looking for a law firm to evaluate this case and, if the evidence supports it, to pursue recovery of our properties and punitive damages against those responsible. Ideal candidates will have experience in civil fraud, property law, RICO, or federal litigation, but more important than the specialty is the willingness to examine a well-documented case and take it as far as the evidence leads.
We are prepared to pay. We are open to discussing contingency, hourly, or hybrid fee structures. We estimate the homes we lost are worth approximately $2 million as-is. Given the documented evidence of fraud, evidence tampering during a deposition, and a conspiracy operating under color of law, there may also be substantial grounds for punitive damages. We anticipate legal costs in the range of $50,000 to $100,000 or more and have no illusions about the expense or the risk. But the value of what was taken, and the clarity of the paper trail, makes this a credible case for a firm that handles serious fraud litigation.
Everything we have is here on this site: the title reports, the deposition transcript, the private investigator's invoice showing Matson Kelley paid to locate the woman he claimed had hired him, Matson Kelley's own letters, the court rulings, and the Old Republic title insurance policy confirming our ownership. The documents are laid out chronologically and available for download. We are not asking anyone to take our word for any of this; we are asking someone to read the evidence and decide whether it holds up.
Our YouTube channel, 175,000 subscribers, 50 million views, fifteen years of home restoration content, provides a public platform if and when the time comes to hold these people accountable. But the first step is legal. We need a firm willing to fight this case on its merits, and we will pay what that work is worth.
To discuss representation, contact us at [email protected].
Paul Sulla's Indictment, Conviction, and Five-Year Sentence
Paul Joseph Sulla, Jr., the attorney who represented us, was also prosecuted in a separate federal case involving affordable housing on Hawaii's Big Island. The U.S. Department of Justice announced that a federal grand jury indicted him on July 21, 2022, on charges including honest services wire fraud, conspiracy, and money laundering.
The Justice Department reports that a jury convicted Sulla on June 4, 2025, of conspiracy, nine counts of honest services wire fraud, and money laundering. On April 23, 2026, he received a five-year federal prison sentence.
The defendants used bribes to obtain more than $11 million in land and affordable housing credits, yet built no affordable homes. This prosecution concerns the Big Island housing scheme. Our family's Maui property dispute is separate; I believe the conviction is important context for reviewing his conduct.
Justice Department: Indictment announced July 25, 2022 »
Justice Department: Conviction and sentence, April 24, 2026 »
Hawaii News Now: Attorney sentenced to five years for bribery scheme »
For Journalists and Investigators
This site is a public resource: a fully documented case of alleged judicial corruption and property theft in Hawaii, presented chronologically with all supporting documents linked inline. Every claim is backed by something you can download and verify yourself, deposition pages, investigator invoices, title reports, and court filings.
We encourage reporters, authors, and investigators to review the evidence and draw their own conclusions. If the facts hold up, and we believe they will, this is the kind of story that deserves sunlight. We are available for interviews and can provide additional documentation beyond what is published here.
A Note From Quintin Wells, Former CIA

Most people have no idea what high-level judicial robbery feels like until they experience it. Doctors and lawyers recognize PTSD caused by war. Victims of the judicial racket suffer from what amounts to "lawfare" against ordinary citizens.
The distinguished Judge Learned Hand wrote: "[A]s a litigant, I should dread a lawsuit beyond almost anything else short of sickness and death." (Merenda v. Superior Court, 3 Cal. App. 4th 1, 11). What has been done to us has caused us to suffer both morbidly and mortally.